The reconfiguration of the European Union’s common security and defence policy amid transatlantic tensions: from strategic heteronomy to autonomous legal identity

Authors

  • Cláudias Alves Pratas Faculty of Law, Universidade Nova de Lisboa; Universidade Europeia; Privacy and Data Protection Centre

Keywords:

Strategic autonomy; Common Security and Defence Policy; Article 42 TEU; NATO; European Union competences

Abstract

The European Union’s strategic dependence on the collective defence guarantee provided by the United States within the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) has historically shaped the Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP). Recent transatlantic tensions have renewed the need to determine the legal scope of European defence autonomy. This article examines Article 42(2) TEU and arg ues that compatibility with Atlantic commitments does not establish a general relationship of normative subordination between the CSDP and NATO. Through a doctrinal analysis of EU competences, decision -making procedures and defence cooperation mechanisms, it develops a framework distinguishing initiatives permitted under existing law, initiatives subject to additional legal conditions and initiatives requiring changes to the current framework. Applying this framework to Permanent Structured Cooperation and EU defence financing, the article demonstrates that European defence integration can be deepened without Treaty amendment, provided that the applicable requirements concerning competences, procedures and international obligations are respected.

Published

19-11-2026